You might be wondering how Jeffrey Dahmer was apprehended by the police after he killed and dismembered more than a dozen people if you’ve heard of his horrifying acts.
Dahmer, a serial killer and sex offender from the United States, killed and dismembered 17 men and boys in the Milwaukee, Wisconsin, area between 1978 and 1991. He was also known as the Milwaukee Cannibal and the Milwaukee Monster.
When authorities discovered that several of Dahmer’s killings contained necrophilia—the sexual act of corpse cannibalism eating another human and the storage of his victims’ body parts typically their skeletons they gave him the moniker “the Milwaukee Cannibal.” Dahmer, who had been given schizotypal and borderline personality disorders diagnoses, was found guilty of 15 of the 16 murders he had committed in Wisconsin and was given a 15-year sentence on February 17, 1992.
In 1978, Dahmer received a 16th life sentence for a different murder he had carried out in Ohio. On November 28, 1994, Christopher Scarver, a fellow prisoner at the Columbia Correctional Institution in Portage, Wisconsin, beat Dahmer to death. Dahmer passed away as a result.
Since his passing, Dahmer has served as the basis for numerous television programs, motion pictures, and documentaries, including the Netflix drama series Monster: The Jeffrey Dahmer Story, which premieres in 2022 and stars former American Horror Story actor Evan Peters as Dahmer.
In a September 2022 interview with Netflix, Peters outlined why playing a serial killer was the most challenging part he has ever taken on. Trying to commit to [playing this character] was going to be one of the hardest things I’ve ever had to do in my life because I wanted it to be incredibly authentic, but I was very afraid about everything that Dahmer did. Peters remarked. But I would have to travel to very gloomy locations and stay there for a long time in order to accomplish that.
I have to emphasize that the crew was crucial in keeping me on the guard rails; I can’t express my gratitude to them enough, and I could not have performed all of this work without them.
It was difficult to try to have this seemingly normal person who, below it, all, had a vast world that he was keeping hidden from everyone. “I couldn’t believe it all actually occurred. In order to present the narrative as truthfully as we could, it felt vital to be respectful of the victims and their families. The 2022 Netflix documentary Conversations with a Killer: The Jeffrey Dahmer Tapes likewise has Dahmer as its subject.
How then was Jeffrey Dahmer apprehended? Continue reading to learn how Milwaukee police managed to apprehend serial killer Jeffrey Dahmer and how he eluded capture for so long thanks to one of his survivors.
Why Was Jeffrey Dahmer Apprehended?
Why was Jeffrey Dahmer apprehended? On July 22, 1991, Dahmer promised three guys $100 at a pub to accompany him to his apartment where they would take nude pictures in exchange for their company. Tracy Edwards, one of the three males, accepted the offer.
However, when Edwards walked into Dahmer’s apartment, he smelt something awful and saw many boxes of hydrochloric acid lying on the floor, which Dahmer claimed he used to clean bricks. Dahmer put a handcuff on Edwards’ wrist after asking him to tilt his head to look at his tropical fish during their talk. (He attempted to handcuff both of his wrists but failed.)
Edwards accompanied Dahmer to his bedroom to take the naked pictures despite being perplexed and asking him, “What’s happening?” A videotape of The Exorcist III was playing in the bedroom, and Edward noticed pictures of naked guys on the wall. A blue 57-gallon drum was also in the room’s corner, which was the source of the obnoxious stench that Edward had earlier noticed.
Dahmer then pulled a knife from his pocket and told Edwards to remove his shirt. To calm him, Edwards began to unbutton his shirt, but Dahmer demanded that he first remove his handcuffs and put the knife away so that he could do it himself.
While placing his head on Edward’s chest to hear his heartbeat, Dahmer disregarded Edwards’ request. He then said he wanted to devour Edwards’ heart. Edwards persisted in assuring Dahmer that he was his buddy and had no intention of fleeing in order to keep him calm.
Edwards asked Dahmer if they could go back to the living room, where there was air conditioning, and enjoy a beer. Edwards intended to flee by jumping out a window or dashing through the unlocked front door. After Dahmer gave his OK, they went back to the living room.
Edwards next requested permission to use the restroom from Dahmer. After spending five hours in Dahmer’s flat, Edwards hit Dahmer in the face as he stood up from the couch and left through the front door.
Edwards stopped Robert Rauth and Rolf Mueller on the corner of North 25th Street in Milwaukee at roughly 11:30 p.m. that evening. When the officers observed Edwards’ handcuffs on his wrist, Edwards told them that a “freak” had abducted him. Edwards consented to accompany the officers back to Dahmer’s apartment when the handcuff keys for the officers failed to free Dahmer from his restraints.
Edwards informed the officers that Dahmer also threatened him with a knife and said he wanted to eat his heart when they got to Dahmer’s unit, Apartment 213, and that’s when Dahmer admitted to putting the handcuffs on Edwards. Dahmer just pointed the officers to a key on his bedside dresser without responding to Edwards’ allegations.
One of the cops, Mueller, observed a knife beneath Dahmer’s bed in the bedroom along with an open dresser that had Polaroid images of severed human bodies. When Mueller showed the pictures to Rauth in the living room, Rauth remarked, “These are for real.
Dahmer fought with the officers to escape being arrested when he saw Mueller holding the photos, but the officers eventually overpowered him and handcuffed him. When Mueller opened Dahmer’s refrigerator after he was apprehended, he discovered a decapitated skull on the bottom shelf. Dahmer reportedly told Mueller, “For what I did, I should be killed.”
The Criminal Investigation Bureau of the Milwaukee Police carried out a search and discovered four more severed heads in Dahmer’s kitchen, seven skulls (some of which were painted or bleached), a tray of blood drippings, and Dahmer’s refrigerator.
A corpse and a bag of human parts and flesh frozen in ice were discovered at the bottom of Dahmer’s freezer, and the investigation also uncovered two human hearts and a portion of an arm wrapped in plastic bags on the refrigerator shelf. In the 57-gallon drum, investigators also found three additional torsos dissolving in acid, three more skeletons, two severed hands, two severed penises, a mummified scalp, and two more bones.
There were discovered 74 Polaroid photos in all showing the decapitation of each of Dahmer’s victims. The chief medical examiner once remarked, “It was more like tearing down someone’s museum than a genuine crime scene.”
Detective Patrick Kennedy and Detective Dennis Murphy questioned Dahmer about the evidence discovered in his flat for a total of 60 hours over the course of two weeks. Dahmer waived his right to have counsel present during his interrogations. He allegedly said, “I caused this horror and it only makes sense I do everything to put an end to it.” Dahmer was accused of four first-degree murders on July 25, 1991.
On August 22, 1991, he was charged with eleven more first-degree murder counts for offenses he committed in Wisconsin. Investigators found hundreds of bone fragments near the scene where Dahmer admitted to killing Steven Hicks, his first victim, leading to the addition of a second first-degree murder charge against him.
Due to a lack of evidence, Dahmer was not charged with the attempted murder of Edwards or the murder of Steve Tuomi, a man who vanished in 1987 and is thought to have been slain by Dahmer. On January 13, 1992, Dahmer entered a plea of “guilty but crazy” to 15 charges of murder.
What Has Become of Tracy Edwards?
When he first encountered Dahmer, Edwards, who was 32 at the time, testified in court and was a crucial witness that resulted in Dahmer’s conviction. Edwards claimed that Dahmer was “not the same person” he encountered at the bar during his testimony. “His facial features were unusual… He said, “It was like it wasn’t him anymore.
Twenty years later, on July 26, 2011, Edwards was detained on suspicion of allegedly tossing a guy off a Milwaukee bridge, per ABC News. At the time, he was 52 years old, homeless, and had been hopping from shelter to shelter since 2002.
Edwards said that he and another guy pushed a man into a river from a bridge in the center of Milwaukee following an altercation and entered a guilty plea to aiding a felon. Edwards was found guilty of the offense in 2012 and given a sentence of 1.5 years in prison and two years of community service by the Milwaukee County Circuit Court.
You can watch Monster: The Jeffrey Dahmer Story on Netflix. On October 7, 2022, Conversations with a Killer: The Jeffrey Dahmer Tapes debuts on Netflix.